Jamie Carragher has sparked debate by suggesting that Liverpool should consider West Ham’s Lucas Paquetá as a potential replacement for Dominik Szoboszlai. With Liverpool enjoying an impressive start to the season, few would argue that the squad lacks quality, but the former Reds defender has expressed concerns about Szoboszlai’s role and impact in the team.
Speaking on The Overlap, Carragher shared his thoughts on Paquetá, highlighting the Brazilian’s technical ability and style of play. He praised the West Ham midfielder’s skill in controlling the ball, describing him as a “throwback” and questioning whether Liverpool could look at signing him. He acknowledged Manchester City’s previous interest in Paquetá and pointed out that while the midfielder may lack some athleticism, his technical ability stands out. Carragher then contrasted this with Szoboszlai, stating that while the Hungarian possesses great athleticism, he remains unconvinced about his overall influence as Liverpool’s No. 10. He noted that Szoboszlai has only scored three goals in that role and suggested that Arne Slot might actually favor Paquetá in the position.
Carragher’s comments indicate strong admiration for Paquetá’s qualities, implying that the Brazilian could offer something different to Liverpool’s midfield. However, the question remains whether he would be an upgrade over Szoboszlai. Since his arrival, Szoboszlai has brought energy, pressing ability, and versatility, which have been key components of Liverpool’s playing style. While his goal tally might not be prolific, his contributions off the ball and in linking play have been valuable. His work rate and dynamism allow Liverpool to maintain intensity in midfield, something that Slot will likely consider essential.
Paquetá, on the other hand, is an elegant and creative midfielder with a different approach. His ability to control the tempo, take on defenders, and execute intricate passes could add a new dimension to Liverpool’s attack. His flair and composure on the ball make him a standout performer for West Ham, and it’s no surprise that Manchester City previously pursued him. However, his playing style differs from Szoboszlai’s high-intensity approach, raising questions about how well he would fit into Liverpool’s system.
Liverpool’s current setup under Slot thrives on physicality, pressing, and quick transitions, all of which suit Szoboszlai’s attributes. Paquetá’s technical brilliance would certainly add creativity, but whether he could match the demands of Liverpool’s pressing system remains uncertain. Additionally, with West Ham unlikely to part ways with their star midfielder easily, any potential move would require a significant financial commitment.
While Carragher’s opinion carries weight as a former Liverpool player, the decision ultimately rests on how the manager envisions the team’s evolution. Szoboszlai has already adapted well to the Premier League and offers a unique skill set that aligns with Liverpool’s current tactical approach. Replacing him with Paquetá would be a bold move that could alter the team’s dynamic. The debate over whether Liverpool should prioritize technical finesse over relentless athleticism will continue, but for now, Szoboszlai remains a key figure in the squad.
